Disturbing Behavior

“In Cradle Bay it doesn’t matter if you’re not perfect. You will be.”

Steve Clark (James Marsden) has barely unpacked in Cradle Bay when he notices how the Blue Ribbons, the school's spotless overachievers, smile, speak and behave a little too evenly. His rebellious friend Gavin Strick (Nick Stahl) joins their ranks overnight, and David Nutter follows Steve as he starts digging. He has only one ally in town, fellow misfit Rachel Wagner (Katie Holmes), and what they share is the nerve to ask what nobody else will.