Night of the Reaper

“Nothing is as it seems.”

A package arrives for Sheriff Rodney Arnold (Ryan Robbins) holding a tape of old murders, and it sends him hunting through town for the killer of a babysitter. Meanwhile Deena (Jessica Clement), home from college, takes a babysitting job for the night, and Brandon Christensen cuts between the two until they begin to close on each other. The sheriff keeps pressing play, and the grainy footage keeps flickering on his screen.