Too Close for Christmas

Hayley Parker (Jessica Lowndes) accepts an invitation to spend Christmas with her sister's new in-laws, expecting a holiday that goes exactly as planned. Then Paul Barnett (Chad Michael Murray), her brother-in-law's brother, turns up at the door, and she still blames him for ending her last relationship. Ernie Barbarash keeps the two of them stuck in the same house, and each shared meal and errand makes her grudge harder to hold.