When We First Met

“All he needs is a second chance... to be her first choice.”

Noah Ashby (Adam Devine) has spent three years wishing he'd made a different impression on Avery Martin (Alexandra Daddario), the woman he met on the night of Halloween and lost to someone else. A magical photo booth lets him go back to that first evening, and he keeps returning, rewriting what he says, certain he can make her choose him. Ari Sandel sets his one chance against a girl who is about to be engaged to another man.